Episode 230

The $10,000 Bribe: A Doctor's Calculated Betrayal - Part 1

In Part 1 of the MacNeill Case, we unravel the depraved story of Dr. Martin MacNeill, a prominent Utah physician and former LDS bishop accused of planning his wife’s death behind a "picture-perfect" facade. This episode shows how a pillar of the community utilized his medical authority and social standing to manipulate those around him while leading a double life.


The Forced Facelift: Martin pressured a healthy Michele into an unnecessary surgery to justify his "care" for her.


The Lethal Cocktail: Martin took total control of Michelle's post-op care, insisting on a potent mix of drugs.


The $10,000 Hospital Bribe: Shocking testimony revealed Martin offered cash to a doctor to "save" Michele.


The Safety Fair Alibi: Martin aggressively sought to be photographed at a local event to create a timed paper trail.


The Instant Replacement: Within weeks of the funeral, Martin moved his mistress, Gypsy Willis, into the family home calling her the new "nanny."


00:00 The $10,000 Bribe: A Doctor’s Calculated Betrayal - Part 1

00:37 The Illusion of Pleasnat Grove

02:03 The "Perfect" Doctor. Who are the MacNeill's?

03:53 Cracks in the Facade: The Secret Life

06:11 The Forced Facelift

11:59 The Moment it All Changed

15:55 Forgery

19:18 Betrayal

22:51 A Fake Illness

25:35 Facelift Gift

26:16 The Lethal Cocktail

30:31 The Alibi: The Safety Fair Stunt

31:40 The 911 Call

36:16 The $10,000 Bribe

36:58 The Forensic Failure: A "Natural" Death

38:34 The "Nanny" Arrives

39:38 The Comprehensive Plan


Sources:


Utah Office of the Medical Examiner: Official Toxicology Report for Michele Marie MacNeill (Ref: Zolpidem and multi-drug toxicity analysis).

Utah Fourth District Court: Affidavit in Support of Arrest Warrant (August 2012) – Statement of Probable Cause detailing homicide investigation and witness statements.

Court of Appeals of Utah: Judicial Ruling, STATE OF UTAH v. MARTIN MACNEILL (2017), Docket No. 20140873-CA.

Defense Memorandum (August 2013): Motion to exclude testimony of Anna Osborne Walthall.

ABC News "20/20": After Wife's Death, Dark Secrets of Utah Doctor Revealed.

The Salt Lake Tribune: Investigation into the sentencing and subsequent murder charges of Martin MacNeill.

Deseret News: Martin MacNeill: Was his wife Michele's death accidental or murder? and official case timelines.

The Daily Herald: Reports on federal identity theft sentencing and sex abuse convictions.

CNN/HLN: Investigative coverage of the key players and trial proceedings in the MacNeill murder case.

People.com: Report on the conviction of Martin MacNeill and related family charges.


#MichelleMacNeill #MartinMacNeill #PleasantGrove #TrueCrime #thealibi

About the Podcast

Show artwork for BeachHouse34 - A True Crime and Paranormal Podcast
BeachHouse34 - A True Crime and Paranormal Podcast
True Crime, Paranormal, No BS - From a Gen X'er Who Doesn't Sugarcoat

Listen for free

About your host

Profile picture for Kristine Wirth

Kristine Wirth

Lover of true crime, scary stories, horror films, and ghost hunting. Kristine is a down-to-earth, opinionated, smart-mouthed Gen X'er who enjoys sharing these stories with you.

Support BeachHouse34 - A True Crime and Paranormal Podcast

A huge thank you to our supporters, it means a lot that you support our podcast.

If you like the podcast and want to support it, too, you can leave us a tip using the button below. We really appreciate it and it only takes a moment!
Support BeachHouse34 - A True Crime and Paranormal Podcast
A
We haven’t had any Tips yet :( Maybe you could be the first!